READ

What’s the worth of art without workers?

An AI-made movie is about to hit cinemas, but at what cost?
Tom Gurn
Tom Gurn
Freelance Writer
What’s the worth of art without workers?

Bitcoin is an upcoming film depicting a man who claims to have invented the titular controversial cryptocurrency. It stars big names like Gal Gadot, Pete Davidson, Casey Affleck and Isla Fisher. 

The story follows a man’s claim that he is the infamous Satashi Nakamoto, the still-incognito apparent inventor of cryptocurrency, whose name is attached to a bitcoin purse currently worth AU$128 billion.

Somewhat befitting of the techbro-heavy subject matter, Doug Liman and his producers have decided to use artificial intelligence – in lieu of artistically trained humans – to complete the vast majority of post-production work, including sets, designs and lighting. 

The actors and crew completed the shoot over 20 days in a so-called ‘grey box’ warehouse in London. Everything else is digital. 

There are no real locations or backgrounds used. It’s even reported that actors’ faces and expressions will be tweaked with AI to avoid reshoots or innumerable takes.

Detractors will call this a dark day for the career hopes of hard-working and passionate creatives. Producers and supporters will argue that this decision has saved the production $280 million.

AI-rtists?

In recent years, broad progressions in large language models (LLMs) and other types of generative artificial intelligence have raised alarm bells for workers in almost every industry.

It now seems inevitable that labourers in countless industries – from film to education to journalism – will be replaced by machines that mimic the creative output of human practitioners.  

Professor Julian Murphet is a film and literary scholar at Adelaide University. For him, it’s a nuanced issue which will be decided by the future, for good or bad.

“There are going to be powerful structural tensions between the perfectly understandable struggle to maintain intellectual property laws in the face of technical predation,” he says, “and an equally understandable wish to explore the frontier of new technical possibilities.”

In other words, there’s some sense on both sides.

“It isn’t a logical or a moral question – it is an industrial, political dispute over the right to work and to own the fruits of our labour,” says Julian. 

Films in particular are finished works that don’t always reveal exactly how the sausage was made. In Julian’s words, “We never see in them the struggles that made them. 

“They either justify, or don’t, the compromises and betrayals that took place to get them done.”

If it’s really all down to a matter of taste, at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter what any one individual thinks. If audiences are willing to spend their hard-earned cash on tickets, the decisions these producers have made will be – at least from the perspective of their wallets – completely reasonable. The diets and tastes of the next generation will decide what type of movies will be made.

“If, like me, you’ve been raised on a constant diet of actual photography, AI looks terrible and seems to signal a kind of aesthetic defeat,” says Julian. 

“But if, like my sons, you were raised on games and other kinds of digital animation, it’s all grist to the image-mill.

“There is no one answer,” says Julian. “The immediate struggle is economic and political and, as always, who wins it will dictate the future of the art.”

Who chooses the future?

Whether or not the Bitcoin film is any good will be up to audiences. 

If it bombs in the box office, the people will have voted with their pockets. If the movie is a resounding success, garnering Oscar buzz, critical plaudits and record profits, the precedent will be laid, and we will all have to get used to AI-generated films (or slop) dominating silver screens. 

That includes everything – script writing, facial expressions and even line deliveries. 

If you had a few billion in your bitcoin wallet, which future would you gamble on? 

Tom Gurn
About the author
Tom Gurn
Tom Gurn is a freelance writer from Kaurna Yerta (Adelaide), South Australia
View articles
Tom Gurn is a freelance writer from Kaurna Yerta (Adelaide), South Australia
View articles

NEXT ARTICLE

We've got chemistry, let's take it to the next level!

Get the latest WA science news delivered to your inbox, every fortnight.

Republish

Creative Commons Logo

Republishing our content

We want our stories to be shared and seen by as many people as possible.

Therefore, unless it says otherwise, copyright on the stories on Particle belongs to Scitech and they are published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

This allows you to republish our articles online or in print for free. You just need to credit us and link to us, and you can’t edit our material or sell it separately.

Using the ‘republish’ button on our website is the easiest way to meet our guidelines.

Guidelines

You cannot edit the article.

When republishing, you have to credit our authors, ideally in the byline. You have to credit Particle with a link back to the original publication on Particle.

If you’re republishing online, you must use our pageview counter, link to us and include links from our story. Our page view counter is a small pixel-ping (invisible to the eye) that allows us to know when our content is republished. It’s a condition of our guidelines that you include our counter. If you use the ‘republish’ then you’ll capture our page counter.

If you’re republishing in print, please email us to let us so we know about it (we get very proud to see our work republished) and you must include the Particle logo next to the credits. Download logo here.

If you wish to republish all our stories, please contact us directly to discuss this opportunity.

Images

Most of the images used on Particle are copyright of the photographer who made them.

It is your responsibility to confirm that you’re licensed to republish images in our articles.

Video

All Particle videos can be accessed through YouTube under the Standard YouTube Licence.

The Standard YouTube licence

  1. This licence is ‘All Rights Reserved’, granting provisions for YouTube to display the content, and YouTube’s visitors to stream the content. This means that the content may be streamed from YouTube but specifically forbids downloading, adaptation, and redistribution, except where otherwise licensed. When uploading your content to YouTube it will automatically use the Standard YouTube licence. You can check this by clicking on Advanced Settings and looking at the dropdown box ‘License and rights ownership’.
  2. When a user is uploading a video he has license options that he can choose from. The first option is “standard YouTube License” which means that you grant the broadcasting rights to YouTube. This essentially means that your video can only be accessed from YouTube for watching purpose and cannot be reproduced or distributed in any other form without your consent.

Contact

For more information about using our content, email us: particle@scitech.org.au

Copy this HTML into your CMS
Press Ctrl+C to copy