Get Regular Updates!
|The Moon rock that turned out to be from Earth




The rising Earth shown about five degrees above the lunar horizon in a telephoto view taken from the Apollo 8 spacecraft (24 Dec 1968)

The Moon rock that turned out to be from Earth

All is not what it seems in the world of lunar samples.

The Moon rock that turned out to be from Earth

If you put a Moon rock alongside one from Earth, they usually don’t have a lot in common.

So when Curtin University planetary scientist Professor Alexander Nemchin looked closely at a Moon rock in his laboratory, he realised something wasn’t right.

The rock’s composition was similar to granite, which is extremely rare on the Moon but fairly common on Earth.

Stranger still, the 1.8 gram rock also contained quartz. And the zircon in the sample was very different to every other rock analysed from the Moon.

“This particular piece – there is nothing similar to it in the rest of the 400 kilograms of samples, not at least that we’ve found so far,” Alexander says.

Chemically, it looked less like a typical Moon rock and more like some of the oldest rocks on Earth.

Lost in space

The rock in question is on loan to Curtin University from NASA.

And it definitely came from the Moon – the Apollo 14 astronauts collected it in 1971.

View Larger
Astronaut Alan B. Shepard Jr., Apollo 14 commander, stands beside a large boulder on the lunar surface during the mission’s second extravehicular activity (EVA) on 6 February 1971.

But Alexander’s team discovered something no one else had picked up on for almost half a century.

This rock was probably flung to the Moon from Earth roughly 4 billion years ago.

“We find lunar meteorites on Earth, so there is an exchange of rocks. It certainly happens,” Alexander says.

“Especially considering that, 4 billion years ago, the Moon was much closer to the Earth, so this exchange would be much more efficient.”

Planetary rock tossing

Alexander says this particular rock likely landed on the Moon after an asteroid hit the Earth and launched it into space.

So why were Alexander and his team the first to work it out?

“Usually these things happen out of nowhere,” he says.

“You just look at the sample or set of data and suddenly realise that there is the possibility of a certain interpretation.”

“Even though, sometimes 50 people looked at the same dataset or the same sample before.”

Alexander was able to access the Apollo 14 sample due to a NASA decree dating back to the 1970s – the returned rocks belonged to the whole world.

Scientists can access the lunar samples by applying to NASA with a detailed proposal of the research they want to conduct on the rocks.

Curtin has been lucky to access several Apollo samples over a decade of research on Moon rocks, Alexander says.

Chinese mission to the Moon

Alexander is currently in China, laying the groundwork for any lunar samples returned from the Chang’e 5 mission to the Moon.

He says there’s a lot of preparation to be done before any rocks arrive.

“It’s a complicated procedure,” he says. “Before you even start doing research, you need to open the samples and it takes quite [a long time].

“You need to follow specific protocols so you don’t contaminate your samples.”

For Alexander, lunar research is one area where human beings can work together to solve problems, regardless of borders.

“It has this profound impact on people in creating an ability to collaborate, at least on something.”

Particle Puns


Creative Commons Logo

Republishing our content

We want our stories to be shared and seen by as many people as possible.

Therefore, unless it says otherwise, copyright on the stories on Particle belongs to Scitech and they are published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

This allows you to republish our articles online or in print for free. You just need to credit us and link to us, and you can’t edit our material or sell it separately.

Using the ‘republish’ button on our website is the easiest way to meet our guidelines.


You cannot edit the article.

When republishing, you have to credit our authors, ideally in the byline. You have to credit Particle with a link back to the original publication on Particle.

If you’re republishing online, you must use our pageview counter, link to us and include links from our story. Our page view counter is a small pixel-ping (invisible to the eye) that allows us to know when our content is republished. It’s a condition of our guidelines that you include our counter. If you use the ‘republish’ then you’ll capture our page counter.

If you’re republishing in print, please email us to let us so we know about it (we get very proud to see our work republished) and you must include the Particle logo next to the credits. Download logo here.

If you wish to republish all our stories, please contact us directly to discuss this opportunity.


Most of the images used on Particle are copyright of the photographer who made them.

It is your responsibility to confirm that you’re licensed to republish images in our articles.


All Particle videos can be accessed through YouTube under the Standard YouTube Licence.

The Standard YouTube licence

  1. This licence is ‘All Rights Reserved’, granting provisions for YouTube to display the content, and YouTube’s visitors to stream the content. This means that the content may be streamed from YouTube but specifically forbids downloading, adaptation, and redistribution, except where otherwise licensed. When uploading your content to YouTube it will automatically use the Standard YouTube licence. You can check this by clicking on Advanced Settings and looking at the dropdown box ‘License and rights ownership’.
  2. When a user is uploading a video he has license options that he can choose from. The first option is “standard YouTube License” which means that you grant the broadcasting rights to YouTube. This essentially means that your video can only be accessed from YouTube for watching purpose and cannot be reproduced or distributed in any other form without your consent.


For more information about using our content, email us:

Copy this HTML into your CMS
Press Ctrl+C to copy

We've got chemistry. Want something physical?